October 28, 2024 · Watch the official trailer
Releasing a film about a religious election mere weeks before a presidential one in real life seems at first glance a bit too on the nose.
However, filmmaker Edward Berger’s taut thriller paints in much broader strokes than attempts to heavily comment on American politics and creates a thematically similar, largely escapist look at the struggles men face when presented with opportunities to sacrifice their morals for power.
“Conclave” follows a high-ranking cardinal organizing a papal conclave to elect the next pope as his peers scurry around to rally votes and undercut their rivals, with the film at times turning into a play on classic murder mystery films.
Berger has assembled a plethora of immensely talented character actors for his ensemble cast, led by a magnetic Ralph Fiennes as the dean of the college of cardinals overseeing the election of a new pope and his reluctance to take the role, which at times turns into almost a Sherlock Holmes-style detective, would have been massively overplayed by a lesser actor.
However, Fiennes is able to balance the tightrope between Lawrence’s unease over the position he’s found himself in with his desires to do right by God and his morality in a very unique way.
As Lawrence’s pseudo right-hand man, Stanley Tucci has a different take on the hesitance to ascent to the moment prescribed to him as Bellini, a cardinal in contention for the papacy, and the ways Tucci counter-balances Fiennes’ more introspective turn with a straightforward frankness creates a terrific pairing on which to center a film based on having 100-plus men in a single room together.
In a film dominated by men on a quest for power, it’s easy for a single female performer to stand out simply as a matter of contrast, but even beyond that standard, Isabella Rosselini often steals scenes as a nun with vital information necessary for Lawrence to carry out his mission and her ability to finetune the sometimes demonstrative nature of her performance at a moment’s notice is on par with the turn Fiennes gives in an Oscar-worthy effort.
The weakest point of “Conclave” is the lacking screenplay from Peter Straughan based on the Robert Harris novel of the same name, which gives off a pulpy, airport book quality that undercuts the heady, well-considered filmmaking done by Berger and his team. The twists and turns are attempting to rise to a “House of Cards” but fall much more in line with a Dan Brown “Angels and Demons.”
From a technical perspective, “Conclave” is superb with immaculate attention to detail on every level both visually, viscerally, and emotionally that keeps audiences at the edge of their seats for a political-adjacent thriller that doesn’t always get this strong of filmmaking in the genre.
The unique landscapes of the Vatican City, although clearly not shot in Rome itself, are wonderfully displayed through Stéphane Fontaine’s stylish, sharp cinematography illustrating a majestic color palate of red and blue hues to accent the cardinals’ robes against a largely white and opaque background that has intensity in its simplicity.
The ways in which Berger frames his actors in different angles and perspectives highlights the geographical complexities of locations from close-ups that make buildings seem taller and the seclusion of the cardinals feel more claustrophobic to much wider panoramas that make characters seem exceptionally small in hauntingly vast settings.
For dramas that have been released in 2024, “Conclave” features the most dynamic, interesting perspective visually and the ways each element of production design from set dressing and location scouting to costuming and makeup is elevated and accented in the visual tapestry of the film.
Almost overwhelmingly so, the score from composer Volker Bertelmann setting the tone to “Conclave” has a deep, rich, intense, foreboding nature to it, at times harkening back to a soundtrack one might expect from a bombastic Christopher Nolan film that feels out of place here but is very much in character for Berger as a filmmaker such a robust score.
Each of the technical elements in “Conclave” are some variations on mastery and will prove to be among the strengths of the film as it contends for major award consideration this fall on its way to a potential best picture nod at the Academy Awards.
While one of the film’s major twists might find some audiences with a sour taste in their mouths, the technical and artistic highs of “Conclave” largely outweigh its pulp and make the film worth checking out on the big screen.
