November 15, 2026 · Watch the official trailer
Biopics were once a staple of prestige drama, giving audiences an entry point into parts of history they might know only in passing. Films such as “Apollo 13,” “The Imitation Game” and “Amadeus” found extraordinary stories in a failed moon mission, a wartime codebreaking operation and the life of a composer whose music was more familiar than the man himself. The best of these films could leave audiences thinking about what they might do in their own lives. Over the past decade, the genre has increasingly traded that sense of discovery for the comfort of recognition.
The change took hold with jukebox biopics, which tell the stories of musicians through their own discographies. At their best, these films intertwine the visual artistry of cinema with a musician’s perspective on the world. The format reached an awards-season high point when Rami Malek won an Academy Award for playing Queen frontman Freddie Mercury in “Bohemian Rhapsody.” In the years since, audiences have seen films about Elton John, Amy Winehouse, Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen and, most recently, Michael Jackson. The weaker entries are structured like bad action movies, with just enough dialogue to carry audiences from one set piece to the next. The question of where a song fits into an artist’s life gives way to a simpler one. How does the movie get to the next song?
“Green Book” director Peter Farrelly brings that same impulse to the making of a movie in “I Play Rocky,” a film that’s half original drama about the circumstances that produced one of cinema’s unlikeliest Best Picture winners and half nostalgia porn. Every so often, it nudges the audience as if to say, “Remember that scene from Rocky?” Then it shows how they did it.
Peter Gamble’s screenplay takes a Wikipedia-like approach to introducing a young Sylvester Stallone and showing how he wrote the world’s most famous boxing movie in three and a half days. An underwritten romance with Stallone’s first wife, Sasha Czack, feels shoehorned in to satisfy a producer’s note. Farrelly’s laid-back direction leaves the story plodding whenever his actors can’t supply the depth missing from the page. On paper, “I Play Rocky” shouldn’t work at all. Anthony Ippolito makes it work by inhabiting Stallone as both the man himself and the actor playing Rocky, sometimes in the same moment.
Ippolito only approximately resembles a young Stallone. The transformation comes from his physique, his gait, the way he stands and, especially, the pitch and cadence of his voice. There are moments when he seems so much like Stallone that it feels as though the actor has been digitally de-aged to play himself. That impression is strongest when Ippolito steps into the frame to recreate scenes from the 1976 film, where the familiarity of the images can make a dramatization feel briefly like a documentary.
Late in the film, Stallone and Jay Duplass’ John G. Avildsen, the director of “Rocky,” go back and forth over an emotional scene between Rocky and his manager, Mickey. The setup feels plainly dramatized, yet the instant Ippolito stands in the doorway and delivers Rocky’s dialogue, it becomes remarkably easy to believe Stallone is standing there. Farrelly and cinematographer Sean Porter frame him with such fidelity to the original that there’s room to notice how precisely Ippolito shifts from Stallone the actor into Rocky. The film’s desire to copy nearly everything about the classic boxing movie is both its greatest technical strength and its biggest crutch. Farrelly’s strongest camerawork comes when he fully embraces the work of better directors and cinematographers. In the doorway scene, that exacting recreation makes Ippolito’s transformation all the more striking.
The larger ensemble is less successful. AnnaSophia Robb is fine as Czack, though the screenplay gives her little to do beyond suggesting how Stallone drew on his marriage for Rocky and Adrian’s relationship. The always reliable Tracy Letts, as studio executive Sandy Maddox, helps Ippolito carry the first half. An attempt to explore Stallone’s uneasy relationship with his father, Frank Stallone Sr., is too scattered to give Matt Dillon and Ippolito time to establish a believable dynamic.
Meant to be a prestige Thanksgiving film with crowd-pleasing appeal and awards-season potential, “I Play Rocky” is far more successful as a holiday crowd-pleaser. Its nostalgia and affection for “Rocky” bring back some of the feel-good moments that made the original a breakout hit. The film’s clearest shot at awards recognition is Ippolito, whose inhabitation of Stallone is dynamic and exacting, often even superior to Malek’s Oscar-winning work as Mercury in “Bohemian Rhapsody.” In a slate of five Best Actor nominees, Ippolito would fill the slot for a transformative performance as a familiar figure, though it’s hard to see a campaign gaining enough momentum to put him in serious contention.
The communal experience of seeing “I Play Rocky” in a packed theater with diehard “Rocky” fans might elevate the film as a whole. For more casual audiences, there’s little about the film that demands a trip to the theater.

Leave a Reply